Josh Ritter’s Other New World

6 May

The Show Must Go On

Robert Caro, an American biographer, once said,”You come in off the street, through the doors of the theater. You sit down. The lights go down and the curtain goes up. And you’re in another world.”

So Runs the World Away

“Curtains,” the first song on Josh Ritter’s fifth LP So Runs the World Away, prepares listeners for their 13 track journey into Ritter’s world. As “Curtains” ends, and the symbolic curtain rises, a flash of white light envelopes the listener and entraps them in a state of sensory paralysis where listening is the only option. A hyperbole, yes, but, not by much. Ritter’s new conquest is pure music gold. The album has a wonderful diversity of songs that combine ethereal sounds, bare acoustic riffs, Ritter’s keen sense of the existential lyric and his Springsteen-like croon (and troubadour status). Each song is engaging and brilliant in its own way, never repeating the same musical concept twice. Ritter has proven his ability to create skilled music before, but, as Bob Boilen of NPR’s “All Song’s Considered” program said, “this one took my breath away.”

In the album’s expansive “Another New World,” Ritter tells the tale of a polar explorer who is forced to sacrifice his beloved ship in order to survive the cold. It is a maritime love story; a type of lyric that Ritter has mastered. The explorer’s ship is called the Annabel Lee. Now, quick English lesson. Who has a poem named “Annabel Lee.” The only difference is the poem is not about a ship. Edgar Allen Poe wrote the story of Annabel Lee who is frozen and killed by angels. Ritter’s story is similar. His guitar picking sounds like the trochaic rhythm in Poe’s poem. This is a wonderful touch that may often go unnoticed. It is important to realize how intelligent Ritter, the son of two neuroscientists actually is…in English? What? Anyway, the song is euphonious and the lyric is masterful. It almost sounds like an optimistic dirge which I understands makes no sense at all. I believe the Annabel Lee can be used as a working symbol for Ritter’s album. Ritter himself is the mariner, and his companion, the ship, is his work on this album. In order to fully understand the album’s intimate intricacies, we must take apart the boat and, in a sense, use its contents for their potential warmth. So, let’s explore the inner portions of Ritter’s Annabel Lee.

The album, or ship for our purposes, consists of several of Ritter’s creative ideas. We are sent on a journey through an elegiac opener, to the odd affair between a recently awoken mummy and a pretty archaeologist (that is most similar to Ritter’s “The Temptation of Adam,” an unexpected lyrical chef-d’oeuvre documenting a romance in a nuclear missile silo), to a mock “Folk Bloodbath” that pins classic murder ballad names against each other, into a Paul Simon like “Lark,” and then back out again into a scientific/angelic “Orbital.” And, in the frenzy of travel, Ritter never misses an emotional moment. Each song has an underlying message behind its tender melody and wonderfully scripted lyric. This is what propels this album to a new level.

Ritter ends “Another New World” with a repetition of the verse:

“Sometimes at night in my dreams
comes the singing of some unknown tropical bird
and I smile in my sleep thinking
Annabel Lee had made it to Another New World”

And, this is absolutely true. Ritter’s own Annabel Lee, So Runs the World Away, reaches the a high pedestal of a jewelled release that, in my opinion, goes down as Ritter’s magnum opus at this stage of his career, and, is an early favorite for best album of the decade (to be compiled in December of 2019). It propels him to a symbolic “New World,” and Ritter should be proud and certainly smile at this. His, “Annabel Lee…made it to Another New World.”

“The Curse”

6 Responses to “Josh Ritter’s Other New World”

  1. fattakin May 19, 2010 at 4:00 am #

    Hi, I have been hammering Josh’s new album since release and seeing him a few weeks ago on the current tour.

    This is an excellent review of the album, as it does try and understand some of the detail that Josh has put into it. ‘The Curse’ was my standout favourite on the album but in the last week I found myself drawn to ‘Another New World’ and it was wanting to know if he based it on Frankins doomed polar expediation that brough me to your site via google. I too got the feeling that he was almost singing to himself. He is doing some good work with the band over the last few albums, long may it continue. Looking forward to his novel, i think he’ll do a good job.

    Now time to bookmark your site and have a look through your archives!


    • Matt Coleman May 28, 2010 at 10:04 am #

      Thank you very much fatty. Your content on is great. I love looking through music sites and finding gems like yours. Ritter’s album is just breathtaking. I just got home from a 10-day trip to Israel and I listened to some of the tracks on repeat. They don’t get old. Thanks!

  2. sandwrider August 1, 2010 at 9:41 pm #

    Disagree. Found this album not nearly as engaging as previous, not much variety of music/mood, most songs slow and repetitious. Slow is ok but there should be more variety. Lyrics not as clever as usual except for Another New World, the only song I found worth saving.


  1. Tadpole Audio » Blog Archive » Storyteller Series / Josh Ritter’s “Another New World” - August 17, 2010

    […] and froze to death.  The strongest indicator of the connection though, I found in an article by The Music Court, who pointed out that the trochaic rhythm in Ritter’s guitar-picking emulates that of Poe’s […]

  2. The Best Songs of 2010: #4: “Another New World” by Josh Ritter « The Music Court - December 27, 2010

    […] in May, I reviewed the album ( and here is what I wrote about “Another New […]

  3. the sea turned the color of sky, turned the color of sea, turned the color of ice | Light, Rhythms & Melody - March 20, 2013

    […] to the blog, A Music Court, the meter of the poem Annabel Lee and the picking pattern in the original song by Ritter is the […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: